To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
The soles of these shoes continually separate from the shoe. Shoe Goo helps but difficult to adhere when the separation on the rubber sole itself. Other than that, the shoe is Great. Comfortable and the uppers are durable. Lightweight too. Wish the sole were stitched AND glued. Oh well, the sole separation killed it for me.
Purchased this product for my partner. He works in construction, less that 30 days in the show was coming apart and the shoe was replaced. The new shoe same thing. Purchased July 2020 2 pair in 3 months and they are trashed. The bottom is coming apart on the second pair.
TLDR: Really wanted to like the shoes, but after trying THREE separate pairs, ended up buying Keen Flints.
Purchased based on 4.5*+ and 260+ reviews on Amazon. I really wanted to like this shoe, but I didn't have the same great experience as everyone else. Three lessons learned:
1.) ORDER A HALF SIZE SMALLER!! This has already been mentioned on here. Wish I had read the reviews more carefully, but you need to order this shoe a half size smaller because it runs slightly larger, in my experience.
2.) HAD A DEFECT Ordered the correct size (2nd shoe), but the shoe had a defect. The heel lock (its supposed to keep your heel from moving around so you don't get rubbing) actually dug into my achilles only on the right shoe. The left shoe fit very well and was very comfortable
3.) AMAZON IS GREAT, BUT THE SHOE ISN'T THAT "COOL" They sent me a replacement next-day, but by then this was my third pair and I needed them for work. Ended up ordering a pair of Keen Flint Mids which were very very comfortable and fit great. As other reviewers have mentioned, I didn't notice the Atlanta being that much cooler after wearing them for a whole day (while digging into my achilles) than the Flints that I am keeping.