Best Rated in Eyeliners

Compare the most helpful customer reviews of the best rated products in our Eyeliners shop. These products are shortlisted based on the overall star rating and the number of customer reviews received by each product in the shop, and are refreshed regularly.

Top rated products in Eyeliners

4.4 | 4,081 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Bought for my daughter and daughter in law and they had been looking at this product and it will make getting ready for work a lot shorter.
        Read more
By Susan Scott
I didn't expect it to work as well as it did - but it worked really well!! So much easier than drawing a cat's eye by hand! Nice and dark as well.
        Read more
By Dovie
What good is it's waterproof but the stencil end it's not professionally accomplished as it's advertising. Delivery to my destination and to me was quick and there were no signs of damage. Thank you
        Read more
By Lalita Singh
1 offer from product price
4.4 | 1,511 customer ratings
85% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Perfect
        Read more
By Anji
It is a great product at a very reasonable price. Easy to apply and just the subtle kind of color i wanted.
I have darkest brown color and it just blends beautifully.
        Read more
By Happy Customer
Great product should have bought more than just the two. I use them everyday as I have no eyebrows thanks to over plucking when young.
        Read more
By Carol
4.3 | 928 customer ratings
81% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Used this for my scene look, I found it harder to use than a pencil liner but it's definitely good
        Read more
By WB
I would recommend
        Read more
By Chloe Wilson
Great product,easy to apply.Will order again.
        Read more
By Usha
4.3 | 630 customer ratings
83% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Rimmel make up is always good stuff
        Read more
By Janene Tessari
Good smooth makeup
        Read more
By Steph Silver
Does the job but still smudges under my eye eventuallyas with every other eyeliner I buy. I was hoping it would be the one to stay. Formula is very nice, creamy and great colour payoff. No dragging
        Read more
By Lucy
1 offer from product price
4.3 | 623 customer ratings
82% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I always love Rimmel make up
        Read more
By Janene Tessari
Really nice colour
        Read more
By Janene Tessari
Waterproof Nice colour
        Read more
By PIA
2 offers from product price
4.2 | 2,938 customer ratings
78% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
I love buying these, truly one of the best eyeliners around and reasonably priced too
        Read more
By V
Fantastic color, easy to apply, really thin tip for precise application.
        Read more
By Louise
I liked it. The brush is perfect to apply a thin or thick liner
        Read more
By Padmavati
4.2 | 1,441 customer ratings
79% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
My eyes react badly to eyeliner and kohl usually - I have no such allergy problems with this product.
It is also soft so goes on smoothly and can be deliberately smudged, but then 'dries' so I don't end the day looking like a panda bear.
My eyelids are 70yo, so a smooth finish is no mean feat. 😊
        Read more
By Trish Kroll
Great for those who still love the pencil eye!
        Read more
By S.C.
Great product
        Read more
By tammy horn
1 offer from product price
4.2 | 480 customer ratings
77% of the ratings are 4-stars or 5-stars
Easy to use,perfect lines
        Read more
By naghmeh
Tends to be a little bit flaky. Not the greatest.
        Read more
By LJ
really flaky -_-
        Read more
By Sara